How Both Avoidant AND Anxious Partners Block Emotional Intimacy
In many relationships, we often hear about the challenges that avoidant and anxious partners face when it comes to emotional intimacy. But what's not often discussed is that, although these two attachment styles approach intimacy from different angles, they both fear it deeply—and they block it in equal, but distinct ways. Understanding these dynamics can help both partners break free from the negative cycle and find their way back to emotional closeness.
Why Do Avoidant Partners Fear Emotional Intimacy?
For avoidant partners, emotional intimacy feels like an overwhelming challenge. They don’t know how to give it, and even when it’s offered, they often don’t know how to receive it. The reason? Emotional expression wasn’t something they learned or felt safe to explore during childhood.
They may have been raised in environments where emotions were either dismissed or not openly discussed, leaving them ill-prepared for managing emotional experiences—whether their own or their partner's. As a result, when their partner reaches out emotionally, the avoidant partner often feels flooded and unsure of how to respond, which can feel like a failure in their eyes.
How Do Avoidant Partners Block Emotional Intimacy?
The most common defense mechanism for avoidant partners is to block their feelings of overwhelm, often through avoidance. This can manifest in various ways: they may retreat, invalidate their partner’s feelings, or even fight back, all in an attempt to shield themselves from what feels like an emotional "failure."
What avoidants are truly rejecting is not their partner—but the fear and shame they feel when they can't meet their partner’s emotional needs. This rejection often sends the message to their partner, "I'm rejecting you," when in reality, it’s a defense against their own internal turmoil.
How Do We Know Avoidant Partners Want Emotional Intimacy?
The key indicator that avoidant partners want emotional intimacy lies in their overwhelming emotional response. If they didn’t care, they wouldn’t feel so overwhelmed by their partner’s needs. The fact that they react so strongly demonstrates that they deeply desire connection and emotional closeness. However, the fear of failure is so powerful that it often leads them to retreat, even when they want the opposite.
In some cases, if the avoidant partner feels like it’s hopeless to meet their partner’s needs, they may pull away entirely. But it’s important to understand that this isn’t usually a deliberate abandonment—it’s often a result of feeling like they’re failing constantly in the relationship.
Why Do Anxious Partners Fear Emotional Intimacy?
For anxious partners, the fear of emotional intimacy stems from deep-rooted insecurity and past experiences with inconsistent caregiving. Their primary fear is abandonment—whether real or perceived. This fear is tied to childhood experiences where love and affection were often unpredictable, leading anxious partners to believe that intimacy inevitably leads to being left behind.
Since they can’t trust their partner's emotional availability, they can never fully settle into the relationship. Every moment of closeness feels fragile and fleeting, and they worry that their partner will eventually withdraw.
How Do Anxious Partners Block Emotional Intimacy?
Because anxious partners are hypervigilant to any sign that their partner might be pulling away, they often overanalyze everything their partner says or does. This constant monitoring makes it difficult for them to trust that their partner loves them and that the connection is real.
Their attempts to gain reassurance may come across as criticism, demands, or even controlling behavior. They may even start to create drama or stir conflict to get their emotional needs met. Unfortunately, this only pushes their partner further away, reinforcing the very fears they’re trying to avoid.
How Do We Know Anxious Partners Want Emotional Intimacy?
Anxious partners’ desperate attempts to elicit reassurance demonstrate that they do, indeed, crave emotional intimacy. They beg for connection, but the challenge is that once they receive it, it often feels overwhelming. The reassurance they seek never feels like enough, and their "love bar" keeps rising, which only adds strain to the relationship.
It’s a vicious cycle: they push for intimacy, but when they receive it, they often can't process or accept it fully, causing them to seek more. This pattern leaves both partners feeling exhausted and emotionally drained.
Same Boat, Different Sides
I often tell the couples I work with that, in these situations, "you’re both on the same boat, just on different sides." Both partners are experiencing the same fears and desires for connection, but they’re caught in a storm—the negative cycle of their dysfunctional patterns. Unfortunately, they can’t find their way to each other because they're too wrapped up in their own internal struggles.
The solution is for both partners to recognize how they’re each contributing to the negative cycle. Avoidant partners need to become more comfortable with vulnerability and emotional expression, while anxious partners must learn how to trust and accept the intimacy that’s offered to them. Together, they can work to combat the cycle and move toward deeper emotional intimacy.
Conclusion
Understanding the root causes of emotional intimacy blocks is the first step toward repairing the relationship between avoidant and anxious partners. By recognizing how both partners are equally afraid of emotional closeness, they can start to work together to build a healthier, more secure relationship. If you're ready to take this journey, our Attachment 101 Course offer valuable tools and insights to help you understand your relationship dynamics and foster emotional intimacy.
For more support, feel free to explore our coaching program, or tune in to the Secure Love Podcast for more real-time therapy insights.
“You’re both on the same boat, just on different sides, and the storm is the negative cycle that keeps you apart.”
Other Posts You Might Like:
Learn how the D.E.A.R M.A.N. method can help you express yourself clearly, set boundaries, and resolve conflict while maintaining emotional connection in your relationship.